Okay– so as I mentioned in my earlier post confession#1 , I do enjoy wine from time to time….. And, now will pose the question to investigate: do yoga and wine mix? This is the line of questioning with which my mind sometimes rankles: As I progress along my yogic path: do I need to forgo the enjoyment of having a glass or two of wine with dinner? Is this a detour on my road to greater inner freedom, true spirituality, and ultimate enlightenment?
I would like to feel I have the “answer” here for myself as well as anyone else who may be pondering what it actually means to follow a true yogic path. Is it not possible to continue to be aware, delve into self-inquiry, be present on my spiritual path and enjoy wine with an evening meal? Sure— as long as I am not overindulging– right? Moderation of all pleasures of the body and mind is certainly a prerequisite to the path of yoga. – so a glass or two of wine with dinner doesn’t seem to be pushing any major boundary; yet– perhaps it depends on how strictly one wishes to pursue the path of yoga, how one interprets such a path, and how much one believes his/her life should reflect and be in tune with the ancient yoga teachings…..
From a strictly Ayurvedic perspective, alcohol– by its very nature– is tamasic, meaning it is not fresh or light– belonging more to the realm of darkness and ignorance. Anything tamasic in nature (think red meat and fermented foods) can add to aggressive disturbances in the mind and body, increasing the pitta dosha. If we are really working toward enlightenment or some form of attaining more light in our yoga practice and our lives (lead me from the unreal to the real; lead me from the darkness to the light), we would make certain to keep our diets and overall lifestyle more sattvic in nature (that is, simple, light, fresh, pure and good)– sans alcohol!
One the one hand, I definitely eat a pretty simple, sattvic diet — although I do add meat to my diet to help balance my vatta dosha (read post: wait, I thought I was a vegetarian?) . I practice and/or teach yoga on a daily basis (most of the time). I work progressively on being aware and conscious in my decisions and choices….. I enjoy the work I do and feel I am utilizing and expressing my natural abilities as I help others. This brings me a great deal of satisfaction. I find I am living a life that is, for the most part, consistent with my values and beliefs. So can I consciously enjoy some wine with dinner?
Not to split hairs here, but , on the other hand, alcohol ,classified as a central nervous system depressant, has a tendency to depress or slow down various sensations and reactions as well as lessen one’s inhibitions of impulses and emotions. It has a bit of a mind-altering, or at least, mood altering capacity, dulling the senses and adding a bit of cloudiness to the mind. Alcohol usage can easily become habitual, sort of the opposite of mindful (and, of course, addictive for some).
Thus, as I am working toward clarity and toward a path of consciousness, and greater conscious feeling, I am compelled to examine the compatibility of wine and yoga. Does wine have the capacity to impede my path to awareness? - Does it interfere with my intention to live a true, authentic life…..?
Intention– is a very significant concept here. If I make an intention to find liberation or inner freedom and experience my spirit, delving into material pleasure or enjoyments, especially those which seem to have less than an illuminating effect—i.e., wine in this case, seems somewhat counterproductive. Yet, my enjoyment of good, simple food and my acquired appreciation of wine over the past several years bring me a certain amount of joy, which I believe needs to be part of the yoga path— a necessity to a life worth living. I want to appreciate what life has to offer. I am quite present with this joy and find that I do not need to seek out this form of pleasure in order to lose myself or cope with my present reality.
I am sure this can be a very slippery slope for some and for many of us, sometimes–
Kleshas, or addictive behaviors or disturbing emotions, cause suffering. However, if I am mindful and not compulsive, haphazard, or overindulgent with my behaviors, I can practice mindfulness and moderation in my lifestyle. … And enjoy wine…
No obvious conflict here….. Unless you believe that deprivation is the path of a true yogi.
Recalling the story of the Buddha is significant:
Young Prince Siddhartha Gautama (Buddha before enlightenment) was horrified when he learned about how many people outside of his privileged world suffered and lived in misery. He fled his comfortable life and eventually became an ascetic. For six long and arduous years, Gautama practiced painful self-mortification (nearly starving himself and putting his body through virtual torture) in an effort to reach enlightenment. Yet, he was no closer to his goal. In other words, he did not find what he was looking for through self-denial. He became disillusioned with these methods. Such self-imposed bodily punishment only resulted in dullness of spirit, incredible physical disability and profound exhaustion. He concluded that the body, as a vehicle for enlightenment, must be physically fit to train the mind. . He began to take nourishment again and slowly, he regained his strength and vigor, preparing himself for the greatest struggle which lay ahead. He realized now that a life of self-indulgence would lead him far away from accomplishing his aim. Conversely, he concluded that no one could be enlightened through self-torture of the body. After abandoning extreme asceticism in favor of the Middle Path of self-restraint, Gautama achieved Enlightenment in a flash while meditating under a sacred pipal ( the famed bodhi tree). He was now the Buddha, realizing the middle path must be the proper way to realize harmony of body and mind, just as a precisely-tuned stringed instrument, having neither too slack nor too taut a string, emits a perfectly balanced and lovely sound. The Buddha began his teaching of the middle path, emphasizing avoidance of the extreme behaviors of suffering and luxury and focusing upon the goal of non-attachment.
Although I think I am “grasping” the concept of the middle path and the importance of nonattachment, I find it difficult to put this experience and understanding into words. Experiencing what I may believe the middle path to be is not easily translated into the limited context of language. But I will try: Being in the moment, enjoying life as it happens, experiencing that which brings me joy in a moderate, reasonable way seems like rightful action and effort. Of course, I know as a yogi that happiness cannot depend on outside things, external circumstances. I know I need to cultivate simplicity in my life and create inner fulfillment. I want to experience pure happiness (which is not based on attachment to impermanent things). I know that this true state of being resides in me at all times…. Wine, food, or any other material pleasures for that matter, certainly do not translate directly to inner happiness.
But still– an uneasy feeling and more self-doubt: Am I looking to be the exception? Am I rationalizing my own behavior? If I were really a good yogi, wouldn’t I live a really pure life— practicing saucha (purity in thought and action)?
The idea of a pure life or path– seems to be a loaded concept. As soon as I “say” I want to be something other than what I believe I am — or hold myself to such a severe standard– am I already on my way to corrupting such purity? Am I not working against santosha (the practice of contentment with oneself and one’s life as it is)? And the idea of absolutes and duality is certainly not the teachings of the Buddha (think: Dharma vs. Non-Dharma).
And is it really necessary for me to feel guilty or self-critical as I pursue a sattvic, pure life…… Isn’t nonjudgment and self-acceptance the key tenets of yoga? If I am seeking harmony of my body and mind on my middle path, shouldn’t I accept and be who I am, honoring where I am along this path?
-
Then I am reminded by one of my favorite yoga teachers, Sondra, that this practice is for people like us– just regular people—not some perfected being! Oh I am happy to hear this… In my current incarnation, I have passion, desires, and some areas in which I could definitely improve. The good news for me: I am willing to recognize that I am a work in progress…. there is time for purity… I am just not entirely ready yet. I truly intend on practicing yoga for the rest of my life…. so who knows what’s in store for me!
As I write this post, I realize that I am not just writing to confess or share what I think may be interesting or worth taking a look at (hopefully); but that I am actually engaging in the middle path as part of this self-inquiry. On the middle path, we are to investigate problems from various angles, analyze the findings, understand the truth and find a reasonable conclusion.
Feeling bad about who I am as a yogi is the antithesis of the practice of yoga. It is sad that so many of us judge ourselves constantly and, unfortunately, sometimes use yoga as a vehicle to do this! How many of us, from time to time, have been critical of ourselves for falling short of our own expectations of ourselves as yogis? Finding fault for a whole litany of reasons: E.g., why can’t I balance better in crow pose? What’s wrong with me I haven’t memorized the yamas and the niyamas yet? I had some meat today, am I an ahimsa offender? Why can’t I quiet my mind long enough to meditate properly? Why do I need a cheat sheet to remember how to invoke Ganesh?
All kidding aside, many of us take ourselves too seriously! Yoga is not about whether or not I drink wine or know my chants by heart. It’s about delving into the heart of oneself; about learning self-acceptance and compassion for others; it is about connection to the higher self and to everyone and everything in the universe. It’s about maintaining contact with our core Self in the face of all difficulties and disturbances. I believe I am on the right path if I can reflect upon my actions, thoughts, behaviors – my life- and continuously aspire to positive change. As I practice with an open heart and an open mind– openness and willingness to the possibility of change– and acknowledge and accept who I am right here and now, the divergences and obstacles may still exist but become less and less powerful. I can appreciate what I have and what I do right now without grasping it or wanting to push it away. This reminds me of a simple mantra I remember reading about in Yoga Journal a few years ago:
I love what comes and I love what goes. (http://www.yogajournal.com/newsletter/myj_245.html) — A reminder that everything changes, everything is constantly evolving….. And that as I practice aparigraha (nongrasping, nonattachment), I am more likely to connect with a sense of inner harmony and peace and experience my true nature more deeply.
Tagged addiction, ahimsa, aparigraha, Ayurveda, consciousness, contentment, deprivation, dharma, enlightenment, Ganesh, indulgence, intention, kleshas, middle path, moderation, niyamas, nonattachment, purity, santosha, sattvic, saucha, tamasic, yamas